Lodging Options
Hotels in Montauk
All listed hotels are in or very close to Montauk proper, within easy reach of the party. Book early — 4th of July is peak Montauk season and rooms go fast.
Hotel · Oceanfront
Offshore Montauk
71 S Emerson Ave · Steps to the beach · Downtown walkable
Splurge
$$$–$$$$
per room / per night
The newest and most design-forward hotel in Montauk — beautifully renovated with private oceanfront
balconies, luxurious towels, and attentive service. Located steps from the beach on one side and
walking distance to downtown on the other. Consistently praised for cleanliness and staff.
The kind of place that genuinely delivers on its aesthetic promises.
Highlights
- Private oceanfront balconies (select rooms)
- Newly renovated, modern design
- Walking distance to town
- Exceptional service — highly responsive staff
- Dune view + oceanfront room categories
Good to Know
- 3-night minimum required for 4th of July weekend
- Book ASAP — 4th of July sells out months ahead
- Newer property, limited reviews but very high ratings
- Best for those who want a true oceanfront experience
- Walking distance to Montauk restaurants + bars
Resort · Seawater Spa
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
290 Old Montauk Hwy · Private beach · ~2 miles from town
Splurge
$$$$
per room / per night
The iconic Montauk resort — oceanfront, full-service, with a legendary seawater spa and private
beach club. GiGi's restaurant on-site. Closest walking proximity to the party,
which makes it the most convenient option for coming and going throughout the weekend.
Currently showing as sold out for July 2-6, but worth checking back for cancellations.
Highlights
- Closest walking distance to the event
- Private beach club access
- Full-service seawater spa
- On-site restaurant (GiGi's)
- Iconic Montauk destination resort
Good to Know
- Currently sold out for July 2-6 — check back for cancellations
- Most expensive option on this list when available
- Very popular over 4th of July; book far in advance
- Mixed reviews on service consistency — off-season is better
Hotel · Historic Manor
Montauk Manor
236 Edgemere St · On the hill · Scenic views
Mid-Range
$$–$$$
per room / per night
A handsome Tudor-style manor perched on a hill with sweeping views. More of a hotel-resort
hybrid — on-site restaurant (Monte's at the Manor), shuttle service to town, and a relaxed,
unfussy vibe that appeals to a wide range of guests. A great choice if you want something with
character and a bit of scale without the Gurney's price tag.
Highlights
- On-site restaurant (Monte's at the Manor)
- Shuttle service to town
- Beautiful historic architecture
- Great views from upper rooms
- Very well-reviewed staff
Good to Know
- 3-night minimum required for 4th of July weekend
- Not oceanfront — hilltop location
- Shuttle to town included (no need for car)
- Comfortable mid-range pricing for the area
- Book early — fills up for holiday weekends
Boutique Motel · Local Favorite
Daunt's Albatross Motel
44 S Elmwood Ave · Town center · Near the beach
Mid-Range
$$
per room / per night
A lovingly owned boutique motel that punches well above its weight — described by guests as having
a "1950s Palm Springs feel," with thoughtful room details (robes, slippers, sound machines, makeup cloths),
a pool, and a bar/restaurant across the street owned by the same family. Walkable to the beach and town.
One of the best value picks in Montauk.
Highlights
- Boutique charm — family-owned, personal service
- Pool on-site
- Bar + restaurant across the street (same owners)
- Walking distance to beach and town
- Pet-friendly
Good to Know
- 3-night minimum required for 4th of July weekend
- Best value hotel on this list
- Cozy/smaller rooms — not a resort experience
- Great vibe for those who want local character
- Fills up fast for summer weekends
Resort · Co-op Community
Beach Plum Resort
779 Old Montauk Hwy · Across from the ocean
Mid-Range
$$
per room / per night
A residential co-op community rather than a traditional hotel. Studios, one to two bedroom
units, and cottages all come with full kitchens and apartment-style layouts. Located directly
across Old Montauk Highway from the ocean, with a heated pool, outdoor showers, and BBQ grills.
The feel is more "beach house" than "hotel," which makes longer stays feel homier.
Highlights
- Full kitchens in every unit
- Across the road from the ocean
- Studios, one and two-bedroom units, and cottages
- Heated pool, outdoor showers, BBQ grills
- Good for longer holiday-weekend stays
Good to Know
- 4-night minimum required for 4th of July weekend
- Studios start around $632/night
- Less hotel service, more residential feel
- Best value tier for groups wanting kitchen access
Resort · Across from Beach
Beachcomber Resort Montauk
727 Old Montauk Hwy · Across from the beach
Mid-Range
$$
per room / per night
A classic Montauk resort directly across from the beach, with a pool, tennis courts, and
studio-style rooms with kitchenettes. A solid mid-range workhorse — no frills, but reliable
and well-located. Quieter and more family-friendly than the trendier boutique options.
Highlights
- Directly across from the beach
- Studios with kitchenettes
- Pool and tennis courts on-site
- Quieter, family-friendly atmosphere
- Good mid-range value
Good to Know
- 3-night minimum required for 4th of July weekend
- Studios around $638 to $678/night
- Older property — comfortable but not newly renovated
- Reliable and well-reviewed
Beachfront Boutique
Ocean Surf Resort
84 S Emerson Ave · Beachfront · Downtown walkable
Splurge
$$$
per room / per night
A smaller beachfront boutique hotel right in downtown Montauk — steps to the sand on one side
and walking distance to restaurants on the other. The shortest minimum-stay requirement on this
list, which makes it a good flexibility pick if you can't commit to the full weekend.
Highlights
- Beachfront location, steps to the sand
- Walking distance to downtown
- Smaller boutique feel
- Ocean-view rooms available
- Only 2-night minimum on this list
Good to Know
- 2-night minimum required for 4th of July weekend
- Rooms around $799 to $855/night
- Best flexibility for shorter stays
- Smaller property, limited availability
Boutique Cabins · Scene-y
Ruschmeyer's
161 Second House Rd · On Fort Pond · ~10 min walk to town
Splurge
$$$
per room / per night
A 19-cabin boutique retreat on the edge of Fort Pond, known for its buzzy bar, expansive
lawn with fire pits, and an evolving culinary program. Under new management since 2025
(by the team behind elgrupoSN), it has long been one of the more scene-y spots in Montauk.
Know the vibe before booking: it's younger, louder, and more party-oriented than the
other options on this list.
Highlights
- Popular bar and on-site restaurant (The Grill at Ruschmeyer's)
- Beautifully designed rustic-chic cabins
- Communal lawn with fire pits and games
- On Fort Pond, ~10 min walk to town
- A social hub of summer Montauk
Good to Know
- 3-night minimum required for 4th of July weekend
- Rooms around $812 to $878/night
- Can be loud — not ideal for light sleepers
- Young, social, party-oriented crowd
Worth the Short Drive
Nearby: Amagansett & East Hampton
Montauk fills up fast on 4th of July weekend. These neighboring towns are 15–25 minutes away and offer beautiful alternatives — especially if you're open to making a short drive to the party.
Boutique Hotel · Small Luxury
The Roundtree, Amagansett
273 Main St, Amagansett · ~15 min to Montauk
Splurge
$$$–$$$$
per room / per night
One of the most beloved small luxury properties on the East End — intimate, garden-set cottages,
complimentary breakfast, nightly bonfires and s'mores, and a chef's tasting menu on-site.
Exceptional hospitality; guests return year after year. Only 14 rooms, so it feels exclusive and
calm even during busy weekends. A 15-minute drive to Montauk.
Highlights
- Garden cottages with fireplaces
- Complimentary breakfast daily
- Nightly bonfires + s'mores
- Chef's tasting menu on-site
- Only 14 rooms — intimate and personal
Good to Know
- ~15 minute drive to Montauk
- Walkable to Amagansett village
- Very small property — book immediately
- Rated 4.9 ★ — genuinely exceptional
For Groups
Sharing a House Rental
For West Coast guests traveling together, renting a house is often the smartest move — more space, more fun, and dramatically better per-person value over a holiday weekend. Here's a guide to what to look for and where to search.
Airbnb / VRBO · Budget Split
Montauk Village Cottage
~$800–1,200/night · Sleeps 4–6
Smaller houses and cottages in walking distance of town. Great for a tight-knit group
of 4–6. Split 3 ways = very reasonable. Look for listings in the "Montauk Village" or
"Fort Pond" neighborhoods.
2–3 BRBedrooms
4–6Guests
~$150–300Per person/night
Best for: small groups of close friends splitting costs
Airbnb / VRBO · Mid-Range
Larger Beach House
~$1,500–2,500/night · Sleeps 8–10
A proper Montauk beach house — pool, outdoor space, full kitchen. The sweet spot
for a larger group. Split 8 ways this is roughly the same cost as a hotel room.
Look for "South Lake Drive" or "Old Montauk Hwy" areas for oceanside access.
4–5 BRBedrooms
8–10Guests
~$180–300Per person/night
Best value: big group, own pool, full 4th of July weekend
VRBO · Luxury
Designer Montauk Home
~$3,000–6,000/night · Sleeps 10–14
The full Montauk experience — architect-designed homes with pools, chef's kitchens,
and ocean or bay views. Split 10–12 ways, these become accessible even at the higher
end. Worth it for a truly memorable 4th of July weekend.
5–7 BRBedrooms
10–14Guests
~$300–500Per person/night
Best for: the full Hamptons experience, large group
Tips for Booking
How to Search
Book as early as possible
4th of July in Montauk books up 6–12 months in advance. The best houses go first.
- Search Airbnb: "Montauk" July 3–7, 2026
- Search VRBO: same dates, filter 4+ bedrooms
- Check Hamptons Hideaways for curated listings
- Reach out to us to coordinate shared bookings
Practical Info
Getting to Montauk
Montauk is at the far eastern tip of Long Island — about 2.5 hours from NYC by car, or a scenic train ride on the Long Island Rail Road.
✈️ Flying In
- Fly into JFK or LGA (best connections from the West Coast)
- EWR (Newark) also works — similar drive time
- MacArthur Airport (ISP) on Long Island is closer but fewer flights
- East Hampton Airport (HTO) for private aviation
- Book flights early — July 4th weekend is extremely busy
🚗 Driving
- ~2.5 hrs from Midtown Manhattan (off-peak)
- Can be 4–5 hrs on a Friday afternoon — leave very early or very late
- Montauk Hwy (27) is the main route — scenic but slow in summer
- Parking in Montauk is limited — consider arriving Friday to avoid Saturday rush
- A car is very useful once you're out there
🚆 Train
- Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) from Penn Station to Montauk
- ~3 hrs direct; some trains require transfer in Jamaica
- Summer service is frequent — check mta.info for schedules
- The Cannonball runs express to the Hamptons on summer Fridays
- Uber/Lyft or a rental car needed once you arrive
🚌 Jitney / Hampton Jitney
- Hampton Jitney buses run NYC → Hamptons → Montauk
- Pick up on the Upper East or West Side of Manhattan
- ~3 hrs depending on traffic and stops
- Book in advance at hamptonjitney.com
- Best for those without a car — dropped off in town